Carrier vs. Trane Air Conditioner Review 2022

Carrier and Trane are two industry-leading air conditioner brands. While these two companies share several parallels in certain aspects, a few contrasting features separate them. 

This comparison guide examines the similarities and differences between Carrier and Trane air conditioners to help you decide which brand is the better choice for your home. So continue reading to learn more!

What Are The Similarities between Trane and Carrier AC Units

As two of the HVAC industry’s leading brands, Trane and Carrier share several similarities. Both brands offer a complete, comprehensive lineup of air conditioners. 

Like many brands in the HVAC industry, Trane and Carrier offer their models in three tiers: 

  • Basic
  • Mid-range
  • Premium

The split between each tier offers buyers various levels that meet and accommodate their needs. 

Units from both companies are insulated to minimize noise during operation to make it a much more comfortable experience. Premium models feature various technologies to further promote comfort and control, including a WiFi-enabled thermostat with a touchscreen feature.

Both brands incorporate various additions into their models to boost their durability. For example, both companies coat the AC cabinets with baked-on enamel, which helps protect them from corrosion. 

Both Carrier and Trane’s mid-range and premium models feature louvered cabinet vents, which shield the coils against various hazards, including stones, hail, and the like. 

What Is The Difference Between Trane and Carrier Air Conditioners

While these two top brands share several similarities, many differences separate the two. Here are the main differences. 

Trane vs. Carrier: Reliability & Quality

Trane AC units are known for their reliability, and the company regularly ranks above average in dependability and customer satisfaction. 

While they are a higher-end company, Trane keeps their startup costs low and their quality levels high. 

However, Trane replacement parts can be expensive and sometimes are tricky to obtain, especially in small towns or communities. 

On the other hand, Carrier also has a stellar reputation in the HVAC industry. Its AC units are durable and tend to require fewer repairs. Like Trane, Carrier is a high-end company, but it isn’t afraid to charge its customers for the units.

Many customers are willing to pay the higher price due to Carrier’s reputation as a reliable company providing durable units. Generally, Carrier replacement parts are widely available and affordable. 

Trane vs. Carrier: Price

Trane and Carrier tend to withhold their AC unit pricing without a personalized estimate. Usually, pricing is hard to find on online marketplaces for these two brands. 

Trane and Carrier only allow particular authorized dealers to sell their products, so you generally need a quote from these third-party dealers. 

Trane offers fewer choices than Carrier but still manages to span a broad spectrum. Both provide a substantial enough lineup to accommodate the needs of various scenarios. 

Which is more expensive: Trane vs. Carrier? Both brands are comparable in pricing, although Carrier is slightly more costly than Trane by anywhere from a few hundred to a thousand dollars. 

Use the below table to see the pricing of Trane and Carrier air conditioners.

Trane AC Unit ModelsSEERPrice
Trane XV20i21$8,520
Trane XL18i18$6,460
Trane XV1818$7,080
Trane XR1718$6,460
Trane XL16i17$5,860
Trane XR1617$5,860
Trane XR16 Low Profile17$5,860
Trane XR1416$5,440
Trane XR1314.5$5,025

As you can see, Trane’s most expensive model, the XV20i, runs around $8,520. The least expensive model, the XR13, costs about $5,025. Carrier’s most efficient model, 24VNA6, costs $9,640, while their least expensive model, 24ABB3, costs $4,030. 

Carrier AC Unit ModelsSEERPrice
Carrier Infinity 24VNA626$9,640
Carrier Infinity 24ANB119$6,000
Carrier Infinity 24VNA919$6,590
Carrier Infinity 24ANB717$5,270
Carrier Infinity 24ANB7**C17$5,270
Carrier Performance 24ACB717$5,270
Carrier Performance 24ACC617$5,150
Carrier Performance 24APB617$5,150
Carrier Comfort 24ABC617$5,150
Carrier Comfort 24AAA517$5,150
Carrier Infinity 24ANB616$4,780
Carrier Performance 24AHA414$4,290
Carrier Comfort 24ACC414$4,290
Carrier Comfort 24ACA4**C14$4,290
Carrier Performance 24ACB313$4,030
Carrier Comfort 24ABB313$4,030

Efficiency Rating Comparison

Both Carrier and Trane have some of the top SEER ratings in the industry. 

Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) ratings refer to a unit’s efficiency. Essentially, it is the ratio of its cooling output over a standard cooling season, divided by its energy usage in Watt-Hours. So, the higher the rating, the more energy-efficient the unit. 

Carrier units surpass Trane units in energy efficiency, with Carrier’s leading model boasting ratings up to 26 SEER and Trane’s top unit featuring ratings up to 21 SEER as shown in the tables above. 

Noise Level Comparison

Trane and Carrier offer some of the quietest air conditioners on the market. Trane’s variable speed units are as quiet as 55 decibels during operation, some of the most silent models you can have installed. 

Carrier models aren’t far behind. Its quietest model has operating sounds as low as 56 decibels. 

A typical conversation is about 60 decibels, which means these units are quieter than most conversations. Quiet units are excellent as they don’t disrupt your daily life as they cycle through running periods.

Usually, units with variable stage compressors are the quietest, while single-stage and two-stage models tend to be noisier. While other brands don’t offer variable stage compressors in their units, Carrier and Trane offer several. 

However, both companies also provide single-stage and two-stage units that tend to be more affordable than their variable speed counterpart. Carrier also offers 5-stage compressors on specific models. 

Feature Comparison

Trane and Carrier central air conditioners have several optimal comfort and control features. Premium units from these brands come with humidity control, a variable fan, WiFi capabilities, a smart thermostat, communicating technology, and are compatible with various devices.

Trane units are compatible with Google Home, Apple Home, and Amazon Alexa, while Carrier units are compatible with Alexa. Carrier offers six varieties of high-end smart thermostats, while Trane only offers four variations. 

Many of Carrier’s smart thermostats allow homeowners to control multiple zones in their home, which is ideal for those with several individuals in the household who have strong, opposite feelings regarding comfortable temperatures. 

All Carrier models have WiFi capabilities, while these same capabilities are limited to Trane’s top models. 

Here is a breakout of features between Trane and Carrier AC units. 

Factors  for ComparisonTraneCarrier
CompressorSingle-stage, 2-stage, Variable-speedSingle-stage, 2-stage, 5-stage, Variable-speed
CoilAluminum Coil 
Spine Fins
Aluminum & Copper Coil 
Normal Fins
Humidity ControlComfort-RInfinity Touch
Smart Home CompatibilityNexiaAlexa, C6r Smart Home
WiFiTop modelsAll models
Smart ThermostatComfortLink IIInfinity, Cδr

Warranty Comparison

The warranty on your air conditioner is a critical component to consider during the selection process. Central air conditioning systems are a significant investment, and it’s essential to look for a company that backs its products. 

Trane and Carrier offer comparable warranties, but Trane’s is slightly better. Consumers who purchase Trane units have peace of mind with the 10-year limited parts warranty and 12-year compressor warranty (10-year on XR models). 

Customers who invest in Carrier units get a 10-year compressor warranty and a 10-year limited parts warranty.

Trane vs. Carrier: Which Is Better?

Selecting a winner between Carrier vs. Trane HVAC is difficult, as both brands offer excellent, high-quality units. While several differences separate the two, they share many similarities. 

When it comes down to choosing between the two brands, it falls to a combination of personal preference, budget, and what is available from your preferred HVAC dealer. 

Units from both brands are comparable in pricing (Carrier is more expensive), offer similar warranties (Trane’s is slightly better), run at nearly the same decibel level, and come with many similar features. 

If you’re looking for a high-efficiency AC unit and cost isn’t a hurdle, Carrier’s Premium units are an outstanding choice. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more affordable alternative to Carrier but still want solid SEER ratings, Trane units are an exceptional choice.

Leave a Comment