Trane vs. Goodman Heat Pump Review 2021 – Which is More Reliable?

Goodman and Trane are both well-known brands within the residential HVAC industry. While Trane tends to sit on the more expensive side, Goodman heat pumps are usually more affordable. 

This article examines the differences between the Goodman and Trane heat pump lineups to determine which of the two is more reliable, so continue reading to learn more!

Trane vs. Goodman Heat Pumps

Before pitting Goodman vs. Trane, let’s examine each individual brand for what it brings to the table. Here are the details on these two heat pump powerhouses.

Trane Heat Pump

Trane offers a lineup of 10 different heat pumps. They are available in sizes from 1.5 tons to 5 tons, creating an inclusive lineup to suit the needs of various home sizes. Like most top brands, Trane divides its lineup into three distinct tiers: XR, XL, and XV series. 

The XR series features Trane’s entry-level models, while the XV series consists of Trane’s top-tier options. 

Trane’s models feature Climatuff compressors, which are one of the most reliable brands in the industry. Certain models offer various bells and whistles to amplify home comfort or ease of use, such as communicating technology. 

Both homeowners and HVAC technicians alike rave over Trane heat pumps, expressing how silent these units are during operation. 

Goodman Heat Pump

Goodman’s heat pump lineup consists of only five models. While the selection is somewhat limited, the sizing spectrum matches that of Trane’s. Goodman offers heat pumps ranging from 1.5 tons to 5 tons. 

Their warranty program is above average, offering lifetime warranties on their compressors with certain models. Each model utilizes a Copeland Scroll compressor, which is also known among the HVAC industry for its reliability. 

Most people in the HVAC industry consider Goodman to be a reliable, mid-range brand. Their heat pumps require a professional tune-up at least annually for the heat pump units to continue to run smoothly, not unlike other brands. 

Trane vs. Goodman Heat Pump Comparison

FeaturesTrane Heat PumpGoodman Heat Pump
Product Numbers105
Available SEER14, 16, 17, 18, 19.5, 2015-21
Available HSPF8.2, 9.5, 9.6, 10, 129-10
Compressorsingle-stage or two-stage, or variable speedsingle-stage or two-stage
Sound Level43-76Not provided
Limited Parts Warranty10-Year10-Year
Replacement Limited Warranty10-Year or 12-Year(Compressor)10-year or 2-year
Size Range1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 3.5, 4, 5 tons1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 3.5, 4, 5 tons
Cost Range$$$$$
Where to BuyAvailable through HVAC contractorsWidely available

Goodman vs. Trane Heat Pump Cost Breakdown

Trane heat pumps tend to be considerably more expensive than Goodman heat pumps, with some models costing quite a bit more. When it comes to affordability with Trane vs. Goodman heat pumps, Goodman comes in first. 

The chart below is based on various Goodman heat pump models. Each system includes a 3-ton outdoor condenser, a programmable heat pump thermostat, and a 1,200 to 1,500 CFM air handler. These three models represent the low, middle, and high end of the spectrum.

Goodman Heat Pump ModelsSystem OnlySystem Installed
Goodman DZSC18$2,170 $6,300
Goodman GSZ16$1,810 $5,480
Goodman GSZ13$1,180 $5,190

A similar setup from Trane nearly doubles in cost. 

Since Trane divides its lineup into tiers, one model from each tier displays the price difference based on the model. 

Trane Heat Pump ModelsSystem OnlySystem Installed
Trane XV19$4,320 $12,090
Trane XL16i$3,100 $9,350
Trane XR14$2,570 $7,530

The cost of the unit is entirely dependent on the size and type of model. For example, the Trane XL16i costs $3,100 while the Trane XV20i costs $4,840 and is considerably more efficient. 

Similarly, Goodman units fluctuate in price based on efficiency. The entry-level models are considerably cheaper than the more efficient models. 

Trane vs. Goodman Heat Pump Best Model Analysis

Listed below are two charts: one displays Trane’s most efficient model, and the other shows Goodman’s best model. 

Trane XV20i Heat Pump Information

FactorProduct InfoScore
Trane Heat Pump Model NumberXV20iNA
CompressorClimatuff Variable Speed4
Sound Level54 dB(Excellent)5
Size Range2, 3, 4, 53
Limited Parts Warranty5 years unregistered, 10 years registered4
Replacement Limited Warranty10 years4
Composite Rating31/40

Note: Pricing is based on $, $$, or $$$. $ represents a range up to $1,500. $$ represent a range from $1,501 to $3,000. $$$ represents $3,001 to $5,000. Higher than $5,000 is represented by $$$$.

Goodman GVZC20 Heat Pump Information

FactorProduct InfoScore
Goodman Heat Pump Model NumberGVZC20NA
Compressorsingle-stage or two-stage4
Sound Level54 to 76 dB(Excellent to decent)3
Size Range2, 3, 4, and 5 ton3
Limited Parts Warranty10 year4
Replacement Limited Warranty10 year5
Composite Rating32/40

When it comes to the technicalities of each brand’s top model, they are relatively similar. They both have similar ratings, although Goodman’s model does slightly surpass Trane’s. The size range is identical, and they both feature 10-year limited parts warranties.

In terms of scoring, these two models score very close to each other, with Goodman’s model coming in slightly ahead due to the affordability and warranty status. 

Trane vs. Goodman Heat Pump: Which Is More Reliable?

When it comes to reliability, both Trane and Goodman heat pumps rank well. However, in terms of reliability over a long period, Trane seems to take the cake. While Goodman heat pumps tend to perform well initially, they don’t hold up as well as Trane’s heat pumps. 

Most homeowners and HVAC contractors will tell you that Goodman’s heat pumps have outstanding reliability but for only a short period. Many customers report issues with Goodman’s heat pumps within seven to ten years of purchase. 

On the other hand, Trane’s heat pumps will last twenty years or more with proper maintenance. As with Goodman’s heat pumps, Trane units require regular inspections to ensure everything is running smoothly. If a repair is necessary, Trane’s replacement parts can be pricey. 

NOTE: Without regular maintenance, any brand of heat pump won’t perform well. For maximum longevity, routine professional maintenance and tune-ups are necessary. 

The Final Verdict

To give a definite answer: Trane heat pumps are more reliable over a long period, while Goodman heat pumps perform well for up to ten years but will cost you a lot less upfront. However, both heat pump brands are excellent choices.

Choosing the right heat pump is dependent on your situation: the size of your home, your climate, and your budget. Goodman’s heat pump lineup offers several budget-friendly options with decent ratings comparable to top brands, such as Trane. 

On the other hand, Trane’s heat pumps boast a lengthy lifespan, additional features, and a price to match. 

Leave a Comment